I would be using the same pattern I used to make Fluttershy (since it would make refining a lot easier if I stick to the same pattern) and she's about 10 inches long from the bottom of her foot to the tip of her nose, not counting her tail which is really long. And then from the bottom of her foot to the top of her ear is about 4.5 inches... so maybe a little bigger than a beanie baby? :I

I've been making plush on-and-off for a few years now, but only recently am I really starting to have a lot of fun with it. I'm just nervous about selling them because I've not done it before.