They sent Kevin Butler a basket of goodies as an apology for ripping off their ad? LMAO that's.... amazing.

Did you want the shiny magikarp charm or regular? either way, johto charms are pretty easy to sell by themselves. I mean, i bought a second set of wooper/quagsire so i could have a quagsire charm outside of my collection to hang from my DS. I decided that I didn't really need the wooper so I auctioned it. The auction ended up paying for both charms. :D; idk if you want the shiny one or not but if you auctioned a gyarados charm? I think that'd be popular enough for you to get a decent amount back. IDK THOUGH.